Aaron Boone Got Away with Using Bullpen, Yankees are All-In

Posted on: October 17, 2022, 10:31h. 

Last updated on: October 17, 2022, 11:04h.

What a great day for New York sports teams, especially the Yankees, who were in a do-or-die situation. They got seven strong innings from starter Gerrit Cole and two hitless innings from their beleaguered bullpen, setting up a winner-take-all Game 5 Monday night in the Bronx.

With the Giants and Jets both winning and massively exceeding preseason expectations, this is a great morning to be a New York sports fan. Even the folks in Buffalo came up winners when the Bills picked off Patrick Mahomes’ final pass in their matchup with the Kansas City Chiefs.

Could New York’s collective luck be turning after 2 1/2 years of everything falling apart systemically?

Well, a lot of that depends on the Yankees tonight as they send Jameson Taillon to the mound against the Guardians’ Aaron Civale, weather permitting. Rain is forecast for the 7:07 p.m. start, but it should be all clear by 9 p.m., which means it’s a great bet that a bunch of people will be bleary-eyed at work on Tuesday morning.

Bringin’ that energy to the Bronx. #RepBX pic.twitter.com/PhrlNgt7Cs

— New York Yankees (@Yankees) October 17, 2022

Of course, that Game 4 win will mean little for the Yankees if they come up short tonight and the fans boo Aaron Judge again, and Aaron Boone ends up getting fired, which has been predicted by Sports Illustrated.

Harrison Bader is the New Aaron Judge

As we told you Sunday in setting up Game 4, there’s a new “go-to” bat in the lineup. Trade deadline acquisition Harrison Bader, who grew up just a few miles from Yankee Stadium in Bronxville, NY, is the team’s leading hitter in the postseason. He put them ahead to stay last night with a two-run homer — his third dinger of the series — to end Cal Quantrill’s Progressive Field unbeaten streak at 44 games.

Keep that one in mind, trend bettors. Because every trend has an endpoint. Even Quantrill’s.

Bader Blast 😤 pic.twitter.com/ZaFyYcTvVY

— New York Yankees (@Yankees) October 16, 2022

All that matters tonight is who emerges as the winner, and the Yankees have a lot riding on Taillon, who was the loser in Game 2 when he allowed three hits and was charged with two earned runs without recording an out when he came in to pitch the 10th inning with the score tied 2-2 in a game Cleveland won 4-2.

It’s ironic that this is the best pitcher Aaron Boone can put on the mound as a winner-take-all Game 5 starter for a team with a $250.8 million payroll. It wouldn’t be surprising for Boone to yank Taillon quickly if a quick hook is called for. It’s all hands on deck on Monday, and New York has 12 pitchers on the postseason roster. All except Cole figure to be available. Clay Holmes worked the eighth last night, while Wandy Peralta pitched his fourth straight game and needed only seven pitches to close out the ninth.

Taillon went 14-5 in the regular season and only faced the Indians once, holding them to one earned run on seven hits on April 22. Civale (5-6 with a 4.92 ERA in the regular season) faced the Yankees twice. He suffered a loss on July 2 in which he allowed four earned runs on five hits in six innings. That’s along with a loss in April in which he lasted just three innings and surrendered seven hits and six earned runs.

The Oddsmakers’ Predictions

The Yankees are favored by 1 1/2 runs and are -150 to -160 on the moneyline. That’s mostly because the stats listed above regarding Civale were run through computer simulators and looked at by traders at the big sportsbooks. They decided that Terry Francona is sending out a worse starter than Boone is.

The over/under on innings pitched by both starters is just 3 1/2, and the odds on Bader homering for the fourth time in this series are at +900. Judge, by comparison, is just +220 to hit a home run. Guardians slugger Jose Ramirez is the only player in this series batting above .300, and he’s on the board at +475 to clear the fences at Yankee Stadium. Josh Naylor is also +475, not including style points while rounding the bases.

If it’s a Cole World, this is Ice. 🥶#ForTheLand pic.twitter.com/hMaSJFTYL5

— Cleveland Guardians (@CleGuardians) October 17, 2022

The Guardians’ hitters have 64 strikeouts against 49 hits, while the Yankees’ hitters have struck out 41 times and have just 22 hits. That should give you an indication of just how anemic the Yankees have been at the plate in this series. It certainly doesn’t justify the nickname “Bronx Bombers” at this juncture.

So it becomes a question of whether Civale has benefitted from the lack of work. He last pitched back on October 5 against Kansas City and got the W. That gave him four consecutive pitching victories and wins in seven of his most recent eight starts. Taillon got the win in six of his last seven regular-season starts, with 38 strikeouts and just eight walks, but 42 hits allowed.

Rain Could be a Factor

Neither team has its ace available, and either Boone or Francona is going to be the subject of some serious second-guessing on Tuesday. That’s while the other manager will be talking about what he plans to do against the Houston Astros and starter Justin Verlander when the American League championship series begins in Texas on Wednesday night.

The Astros are the +150 favorites to win the World Series while the San Diego Padres are +300, the Philadelphia Phillies are +350, the Yankees are +550, and the Guardians are +1300.

Wet conditions generally have no discernable impact on whether a game is high or low scoring. But, they can change the ability of outfielders to chase down balls while running full speed, and they can lead to outfield slips and slides that generally favor the hitters who get hit the ball into wet areas of the field. The infield will be covered by a tarp while it is raining.

And given the anarchy conditions that New Yorkers have been dealing with lately, it is questionable whether the Guardians’ team bus can make it to Yankee Stadium without encountering some sort of unexpected trouble.

A carjacking in the Bronx ended with an NYPD officer being injured, another cop opening fire, and the vehicle crashing. https://t.co/W7hB0Ygr8K

— Fox5NY (@fox5ny) October 17, 2022

Monday Night’s Best Bets

As we did yesterday, we suggest a parlay for New Yorkers who want to Yankees to win. And again, these parlays can be difficult to find because of restrictions at the different New York sportsbooks. Anyone already actively wagering in New York knows the importance of shopping around.

We were able to find this at PointsBet:

• Leg one is Yankees ML (-160).
• Leg two is under 7.5 runs (-120), because three of the four games in this series have gone under, and the Guardians scored just three runs combined in two games vs. Tampa in the wild-card round.
• Leg three is Civale over 3 1/2 strikeouts (-135) because he has had at least five in his last three starts.
• Leg four is Anthony Rizzo over 0.5 hits (-145) because he shares the team postseason lead with a .286 average.
• Leg five is Bader over 0.5 hits (-125) because he’s also hitting .286.

That gets you a line of +1500, and you need five likely things to happen (unless you feel a Yankees win is unlikely because they’re snakebitten.)

15-1 would be a moneymaker that would help shake off that Tuesday morning grogginess if this thing goes into the early hours. As always, we counsel that you wager wisely. And, if you’re attending the game, bring an umbrella and use one of the small private parking lots off the Grand Concourse on 164th or 165th streets. The money you save by parking there can cover your wager, if you so choose. Good luck.